Criteria for manuscript review

This form contains the elements and criteria to be considered for the evaluation of articles proposed for publication in Metode Science Studies Journal.

The journal accepts three types of manuscripts. Those submitted for review are Research papers and Documentary texts, which include reviews on the state of the art of a topic, allowing an approach to the latest advances in a field or discipline, or reflections on this topic from a historical, philosophical, or social point of view, combining an academic character with an essayistic tone.

Should you consider that a manuscript does not fall into this category or have any queries, please contact the journal's editorial team (metodessj@uv.es).

Review Form

1. Is it within the range of the contents of the journal?
2. Does the text meet the journal’s autor guidelines?
3. Article assessment
   a) Contribution to knowledge
   b) Originality
   c) Wording and Style
   d) Relevance of the tòpic
4. Improvement or change suggestions
5. Is the publication of this article recommended?
   a) Publishable without objection
   b) Publishable with changes (minor revision)
   c) Request substantial changes or modifications, which will require a new review (major revision)
   d) Rejected