Review Form

Form

Rate the scientific interest and originality of the article*

  • Improvable
  • Deficient

Rate the methodology used by the author of the article*

  • Improvable
  • Deficient

Rate expository clarity*

  • Improvable
  • Deficient

Rate the management of the bibliography*

  • Improvable
  • Deficient

Rate the writing (coherence, style, structure)*

  • Improvable
  • Deficient

Rate the contribution to the field of knowledge*

  • Improvable
  • Deficient

Assess the adaptation to the Diablotexto Digital standards*

  • Improvable
  • Deficient

Rate the appropriateness of the title to the topic of the article*

  • Improvable
  • Deficient

Assess the appropriateness of keywords*

  • Improvable
  • Deficient

Rate the summary*

  • Improvable
  • Deficient

Overall assessment of the quality of the article*

  • Improvable
  • Deficient

In relation to the publication of the article*

  • Accept your publication 
  • Accept your publication with corrections
  • Reject your publication
Observations:

Record pertinent observations, especially if you consider that the article could be improved or discard its publication.